Tough reforms as vital to Egypt’s 2012-09-09

Tough reforms as vital as loans to Egypt’s reeling economy

IMF approval of Egypt's request for nearly $5 billion in aid would come as a vital boon to its reeling economy but President Mohamed Morsi must at the same time enact tough improves, analysts say.

An economic slump following the February 2011 ouster of Hosni Mubarak aggravated the largest problems inherited from his regime: budget-draining subsidies, extreme social inequality, corruption and poor energy infrastructure. A chief concern is the decline in central bank reserves which have plunged from $36 billion at the start of January 2011 to $14.4 billion, threatening Egypt's ability to import basic goods such as wheat and refined oil products.

The budget deficit is projected to increase by 12.5 % over the fiscal year from July 2012 to July 2013, to about $22.5 billion, official figures show.

Tourism, one of the largest sources of revenue and a job provider for 10 % of the people, has made a modest recovery but security concerns still keep the bulk of visitors at bay.

"Much-needed" support from international lenders "could weaken if the Egyptian authorities are unable to entirely address ongoing economic, fiscal and external challenges," Standard and Poor's warned on Thursday. SP as well said it was keeping Egypt's foreign and local currency sovereign credit ratings at 'B/B' because the "outlook is negative" in light of social and political tensions.

But the agency as well removed the ratings from CreditWatch in a nod to the working relationship between Morsi, who emerged from the Muslim Brotherhood, and the military after the removal of its chief, Field Marshal Hussein Tantawi. IMF director general Christine Lagarde, who was presented with the $4.8 billion loan request during a visit to Cairo this week, said the lender "will accompany Egypt" as it undertakes its challenging journey of reform.

But Lagarde made no firm commitments, saying that the amount, details and terms of the loan programme -- which Cairo hopes to seal by the end of the time-- were still under discussion.

The IMF chief said its support was to be accompanied by an Egyptian economic programme incorporating fiscal, monetary and structural measures, which she said would require "determination" and "political courage".

Some Egyptian commentators doubt that the new authorities could use this loan to sustainably improve the economic conditions of the people.

"This credit is intended to cover expenses (wages, food imports)... to allow the Muslim Brotherhood to comfortably reach the upcoming elections and to calm the economic situation," writes Ibrahim Eissa of Al-Tahrir newspaper.

In the end, "it is the Egyptian people who will cough up" the money to repay the loan, he says.  Ahmad Galal, an analyst at the Economic Research Forum, estimates that Egypt needs $10 billion to begin to stem the crisis, and will have to obtain "other resources" in addition to the $4.8 billion requested from the IMF.

But the effort as well requires deep internal improves to be implemented over the years approaching.

"In the short term, we must stimulate economic activity and create jobs. In the medium term, it is necessary to reform the education system, upgrade infrastructure and tackle the informal sector," among other steps, he said.

Economist Angus Blair, founder of the Signet Institute in Cairo, said that "sorting out the (petrol and gas) subsidies programme to make sure it is better targeted" should be a top priority, along with encouraging investment.