Africa > Southern Africa > South Africa > South Africa’s central bank governor Gill Marcus

South Africa: South Africa’s central bank governor Gill Marcus


South Africa’s central bank governor Gill Marcus faces the tricky task of curbing inflationary pressures while trying not to damage the country’s weak economy. Whether or not she succeeds will depend to a large extent on factors outside her control.

Over the completed year, emerging market policy-makers have fretted about the US unwinding its huge quantitative easing programme. Launched to stave off a depression, it brought down interest rates in the world’s biggest economy and led to a surge of capital to developing markets as yield-hungry investors sought to sustain their returns.

The reversal of that trend will have major implications for emerging markets. The perils for them of the US Federal Reserve cutting its monthly bond purchases or raising rates too quickly were demonstrated in the initial quarter of 2014 at the same time as nations such as Brazil, India and Turkey were hit by rapid outflows that hammered their currencies. Financial officials from those nations were quick to chide the Fed for not taking their plight into account with its decisions.

South Africa, with its fiscal and current account deficits, is one of the additional vulnerable emerging markets, and suffered as badly as any of them from the volatility at the start of 2014.

For Gill Marcus, who as governor of the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) is charged with maintaining the country’s price stability, the new situation presents plenty of challenges. But, rather than looking to blame the US, she says that emerging markets simply have to accept that interest rates in the developed world are on the way up. Furthermore, even if this causes problems in the immediate term, it should be viewed positively because it signals the US’s economic recovery.

“Tapering is presently a given,” she tells The Banker. “We’re going to have a period in which normalisation starts. It’s not for us to be satisfied or dissatisfied [with US monetary policy]. We had a world financial crisis that began among 2007. It’s been almost seven years. It’s imperative that we break the synchronised downturn. So, the US growing and normalising is good news in the medium to long term, even if in the short term [tapering] is going to be painful.”

Difficult hikes

The SARB reacted to the world crisis, which sent South Africa into recession, by reducing its base rate to 5%, its lowest level in 30 years. But this January it carried out its initial raise since June 2008, and the initial under Ms Marcus, who became central bank governor in mid-2009, at the same time as it hiked rates to 5.5%.

The decision was scarcely easy for the SARB’s monetary policy committee (MPC). It aims for inflation of between 3% and 6%, and its estimate figure for this year had recently increased from 5.7% to 6.3%. But it as well has to take into account South Africa’s economic increase, which at barely above 2% is viewed as far too low for a country with such high levels of unemployment and poverty.

Ms Marcus says, however, that the move was necessary to counter inflationary pressures, which were rising half due to the rand’s weakness in the previous few months. “We don’t target the level of the currency, but we try to look at what its implications are for inflation down the line,” says the former anti-apartheid activist. “And the rand had moved completely significantly at that time. We were concerned. Our forecasts were indicating that we would be above the target [inflation] range probably for five quarters. We’ve been out of the target band before, but it’s been a fairly narrow breach and not for a long period. Part of the challenge we have is anchoring inflation expectations. If we didn’t act, we felt that those expectations would dislodge somewhat.”

The MPC met again on May 22, next The Banker went to press. Most analysts predicted it would resist tightening again, mainly because severe mining strikes since the start of the year have further dampened economic prospects.

Nonetheless, Ms Marcus says South Africa has entered a rising interest rate cycle. “But it won’t necessarily happen at each conference or by the same all,” she adds. “We operate a flexible inflation targeting policy. We look at what’s in the best interests of the economy as a whole. Given our concerns about the economy and increase, we’ve been additional tolerant of inflation at a higher level than we would normally have been. We’re trying to transaction with this very difficult dilemma of slowing increase and rising inflation.”

Structural woes

The SARB expects inflation to peak at 6.6% towards the end of 2014, before falling to 5.8% next year. Whether this proves correct will depend on several factors outside Ms Marcus’s control, inclunding the movement of the rand in response to changing US monetary conditions. An extra will be the evolution of the economy, which recently lost its crown as Africa’s major to Nigeria, but remains by far the majority sophisticated on the continent.

The central bank is generally viewed as having helped as much as it can. A recovery presently depends on the government rectifying structural weaknesses, say analysts.

While SARB officials regularly express unease about the South African economy, they are confident that a large public infrastructure investment programme that is under way will any minute at this time start to make a difference. “The reality is that a lot of South Africa’s issues in terms of increase are resolvable,” says Ms Marcus. “One of the major inhibitors has been the electricity supply. There’s no question that it curtails increase because there’s a lot that you just can’t do. It’s a structural issue that should be resolved with new energy coming onstream, theoretically at the end of this year or early next year.”

Inclunding managing the inflationary environment, the central bank has taken on a better regulatory role. South Africa’s banking sector, widely regarded as one of the soundest and best-regulated in the world, came through the world crisis unscathed. But policy-makers, having studied what went wrong elsewhere, placed prudential regulation under the control of the SARB for the initial time at the start of this year.

In addition, they will create a market conduct authority that will monitor issues such as financial inclusion and have better power over banks than the existing consumer watchdog. It will ostensibly be an independent body, although it will statement to the treasury. “We are confident about the banking system,” says Ms Marcus. “But there’s no room for complacency. We wanted to learn lessons from nations that had crises instead of just sitting back and saying: ‘We’re fine’.”

Basel headaches

Part the SARB’s most pressing regulatory concerns in the completed few years has been the rise of unsecured personal lending. Although it makes up only about 10% of total lending in South Africa, a lot of economists have sounded warnings about household indebtedness. The shares of African Bank Investments, a lender specialising in unsecured loans, have dropped significantly since 2012.

Ms Marcus says that while unsecured lending has deepened financial inclusion by bringing into the banking system a lot of people who cannot not afford collateralised loans such as mortgages, the SARB is pleased the market has cooled in the completed two years. “Unsecured lending was growing very fast and in an unsustainable way, at about 30%, in 2011 and 2012,” she says. “Therefore, we spoke to the banks concerned. All of them took measures. And there has been a marked slowdown.”

She cautions, however, that South African regulators have to strike a balance. If they clamp down too heavily on unsecured bank deficit, people will probably turn instead to the loan sharks that can be found on streets throughout the country. “If consumers need financing, they’ll go outside the banking system and use unregulated [entities],” she says.

In the longer term, the SARB has to transaction with new international regulations, particularly those emanating from Basel III. South African banks by presently meet the capital adequacy and leverage ratio requirements, while the liquidity coverage ratio, which is meant to ensure they can survive a short funding squeeze, was resolved at the same time as the central bank established a credit line that can be tapped in emergencies. But the net stable funding ratio (NSFR), designed to make banks match the tenor of their assets and liabilities additional closely, is a concern.

In the case of South African banks, which mostly rely on institutional deposits for funding, conference it would entail them issuing additional long-term capital, which is difficult given the small size of the local corporate bond market.

Ms Marcus bluntly states that South African banks cannot meet the NSFR – which is not due to be implemented until towards the end of this decade – in its current form, and hints that she would not even want them to. “The outstanding matter is the NSFR,” she says. “I don’t think anybody, even in advanced economies, is able to meet the NSFR. A lot additional discussion is needed about its intention and whether it’s doable.

“To meet the requirement, we would have to alter the way the whole South African system functions. We’re not sure that’s appropriate. Obviously Basel doesn’t want to operate by exceptions and we fully understand that. But it’s something we take very seriously given the implications for our system.”

Related Articles
  • Year in Review 2017 South Africa

    2018/01/13 A strong mid-year performance helped lift South Africa’s economy out of recession and back into positive territory in 2017. However, factors such as high unemployment and an expanding deficit could rein in increase in 2018. Agriculture driving economic rebound On the back of a 0.6% quarter-on-quarter (q-o-q) contraction between January and March 2017, the economy recorded q-o-q increase of 2.8% and 2% in April-June and July-September, respectively. The upturn pushed year-on-time(y-o-y) expansion over the January-to-September period to 1%. Much of this increase was driven by the agricultural, forestry and fisheries sector, which rebounded from a drought in 2016 to increase by 21.9% y-o-y over the initial nine months of 2017. In particular, the sector’s third-quarter expansion of 44.2% was the major quarterly jump in additional than 20 years.
  • Top 10 Most Attractive Investment Destinations In Africa

    2017/08/20 Africa’s feverish increase has decelerated in recent years and a lot of nations have buckled under the pressure of falling resource prices, security disruptions, fiscal imprudence and adverse weather conditions.
  • Africa: Making Things Happen at the Bank - 'Not a Talk Shop' - Akin Adesina

    2017/07/02 Dr. Akinwumi Adesina is focusing on five areas to achieve the African and world goals for a prosperous continent since becoming president of the African Development Bank - Africa's major public financial institution in September 2015. He was a keynote speaker at this month's Corporate Council on Africa's U.S.- Africa Business Summit in Washington D.C. and moderated a lively panel with five African government ministers. He as well received the Gene White Lifetime Succcess Award from the World Child Nutrition Foundation. This week, he was named the 2017 recipient of the World Food Prize, a prestigious honor that includes a $250,000 award. In an interview in Washington, DC, Adesina discussed the Development Bank's ambitious schedule and his vision for attracting the increase capital Africa needs. Posting questions for AllAfrica was Noluthando Crockett-Ntonga.
  • Climate change laws around the world

    2017/05/14 There has been a 20-fold increase in the number of global climate change laws since 1997, according to the most comprehensive database of relevant policy and legislation. The database, produced by the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment and the Sabin Center on Climate Change Law, includes more than 1,200 relevant policies across 164 countries, which account for 95% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Moody’s and Fitch issued statements saying that while there were leaving South Africa’s bond rating at “Baa2” and “BBB-”

    2017/04/17 South Africa’s economy faced an extra challenging year in 2016, as soft commodity prices, slow domestic request and an uncertain political outlook combined to limit increase, with prospects for the coming year expected to be only somewhat additional positive. Possible downgrade Allegations of mismanagement by President Jacob Zuma and uncertainty over economic policy continued to impact increase through 2016, causing two leading ratings agencies to put the government on notice of a possible downgrade in the new year.