Europe > Southern Europe > Greece > Leader_Syriza’s electoral win is a chance to strike a deal

Greece: Leader_Syriza’s electoral win is a chance to strike a deal

2015/01/27

The victory of far-left Syriza in last weekend’s Greek general election opens a dangerous new phase in the eurozone crisis. Its leader Alexis Tspiras has demanded an end to the “fiscal waterboarding” that in his view has left Greece trapped in a debtor’s prison. But the rest of Europe, and Germany in particular, have so far stood their ground. If no compromise can be found Greece risks being bundled out of the euro by the end of the year.

The scale of Greece’s problems sets it apart from the rest of Europe. The depression Athens suffered was as deep as any since the 1930s. Unemployment has soared and remains high, and Greece remains cut off from capital markets while other nations borrow ever additional cheaply. Next a rescheduling in 2012, its enormous deficit is mostly owed to other European governments.

It is easy to see why Syriza put deficit repudiation at the heart of its electoral campaign. John Paul Getty once opined that “if you owe the bank $100, that’s your problem; if you owe the bank $100m, that’s the bank’s problem”. Greece’s predicament may from presently on force creditors to the negotiating table. To service its deficit burden would require Greece to operate as a quasi slave economy, running a primary surplus of 5 % of GDP for years, purely for the benefit of its foreign creditors. Even the IMF has dropped hints in favour of some deficit forgiveness.

But Greece’s EU creditors have equally strong reasons for refusing. Caving to Syriza’s demands would come at a high political cost, particularly for Germany’s Angela Merkel, who is harried by the eurosceptic AfD on her right. Other struggling nations would find their own radical parties emboldened by Syriza’s success. No country deserves to live beyond its means indefinitely.

Back in 2011, Greece posed an existential threat to the eurozone. Today, Berlin and Frankfurt are no longer as frightened by the prospect of Greece leaving the single currency. From presently on for the Greek people this would be a catastrophe: a giant economic step backwards and a blow to living standards just as severe as any endured under austerity.

Therefore, despite his jubilant post-match rhetoric, the cards remain stacked against Mr Tsipras. If he is determined to remain in the euro, he and his party will have to compromise. The new coalition government in Athens must continue difficult reforms to ensure better competitiveness. Repudiating all of the conditions imposed as part of completed bailouts is simply unrealistic. Some of Syriza’s programme represents evolution: the commitment to tackle tax evasion and the dominance of the economy by oligarchs. But mostly, Syriza wants to spend money that Greece does not have: on civil servants, free food and electricity and a higher minimum wage.

The EU should respond in kind to any signs of pragmatism from Syriza. On deficit, arguments about fairness cut both ways; those banks that heedlessly lent money before the crisis must bear some of the risk. A programme should be agreed that restores the Greek economy to a level where deficit repayments become affordable. This could be done so that creditors still do not take a writedown of the all owed. The neatest way would be to link repayments with the level of Greek GDP.

A transaction linked to increase would entirely turn Greek deficit into risky Greek equity, which creditor nations will still find hard to swallow. But demanding money back merely to hasten the bankruptcy of the Greek national makes no sense. German voters (and other creditors) presumably want to be paid back in euros and not drachmas.
Related Articles
  • Climate change laws around the world

    2017/05/14 There has been a 20-fold increase in the number of global climate change laws since 1997, according to the most comprehensive database of relevant policy and legislation. The database, produced by the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment and the Sabin Center on Climate Change Law, includes more than 1,200 relevant policies across 164 countries, which account for 95% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Brexit negotiations should treat energy as ‘special case’

    2017/05/14 There are strong practical reasons why the UK and EU should treat energy as a appropriate case during Brexit negotiations, argues a new statement. The statement, jointly authored by Chatham Home, the University of Exeter and the UK Energy Research Centre (UKERC), says finding common ground on energy during the Brexit negotiations would benefit both the UK and remaining EU27, while compromise may be relatively easier to achieve than for other areas.
  • How the IMF Contributed to Destabilizing the Greek Economy

    2016/11/23 The Independent Evaluation Office (IEO) of the IMF recently published its statement on the response of the organization to the European crisis. The analysis focuses on the performance of the IMF in the context of the programs for Greece, Portugal and Ireland.
  • Greece: faith versus sustainability

    2015/07/28 Greece and the EU have faith that everything will work out in spite of the country's debt being a long way from sustainable. What does all that mean for the future?