Asia > Eastern Asia > China > The gas transaction announced last week saw agreement between Russia and China next 10 years of negotiation

China: The gas transaction announced last week saw agreement between Russia and China next 10 years of negotiation

2014/05/28

The gas transaction announced last week saw agreement between Russia and China next 10 years of negotiation. The implications of Russia's turn eastward to seek a new energy partner should raise concerns in Europe over its own gas supply and wider energy security.

Gazprom's share of Europe's gas market reached approximately 30% in 2013. As the Ukraine crisis has soured relations between Russia and Europe, both sides are looking to diversify.

Europe's need to diversify away from Russian gas is hardly new. Russia's tendency to use gas as a political tool to put pressure on Ukraine and Europe has demonstrated the risks of relying on one partner. Additional globally, growing concern around climate change and its impact on national security as a "threat multiplier" has lent support to the world's reduced use of fossil fuels. From presently on events in Ukraine and the Sino-Russian gas transaction have accelerated the urgency with which Europe needs to seek new energy sources.

We still have some time to do so. Despite the transaction with China, Russia in the short term will continue to need the European market. The 38bn cubic metres it plans to export to China is small compared to the 161.5bn cubic metres it exported to Europe in 2013. It is likely that China received some concession on price, given that this was the major sticking point delaying the transaction since the discussions began, but it means that Russia's exports to China will not replace the revenue Russia relies on from its European exports. Russia will as well have to pay to build the pipeline infrastructure to China, and gas will only be transported from 2018.

But there is no doubt that, in the long term, Russia gains the upper hand in pipeline politics over Europe by engaging with an alternative gas partner. It may threaten to divert gas earmarked for Europe to China. In theory, this may be an blank threat, given that even the optimum target capacity of 60bn cubic metres to China is still low compared to Russian exports to Europe. But even so, any leverage Europe had in such gas disputes with Russia will diminish. Ukraine and eastern Europe would suffer most from this decline given Ukraine's current instability. Ukraine seems unlikely to recover its political relations with Russia.

The challenge for Europe is that there is no single alternative that could fully displace Russia's supply volumes or match its price. Developing alternative sources will take time. Liquid nitrogen gas is an option available from a number of sources, namely Qatar, Nigeria and the US, but the cost of importing it will be higher than the cost of importing gas, and new infrastructure will be required to receive shipments.

Renewable energy is attractive from an energy security perspective, but it is not reliable and will not produce quantities comparable to fossil fuels. Azerbaijan and, additional promisingly, Turkmenistan are options. But this will not satisfy European request in full and is only set approaching online for Europe in 2019. Shale gas is a potentially powerful alternative, but it comes with its own challenges. Governments have faced social turmoil against fracking at home; France and Bulgaria have banned it. Reserve estimates can turn out to be underwhelming, as seen in Poland.

Given its position as a gas exporter, Russia was able to act quickly in diversifying its customer base by turning to China. As a gas customer, Europe does not have this flexibility. From presently on Europe can learn from the expediency with which President Putin reacted to the shifting political and economic landscape in the wake of Ukraine to sign a transaction with China. A blend of alternative energy sources for Europe will no doubt cost additional, but Europe's energy security depends on diversification along these lines.

Europe is unlikely to become completely free from Russian gas in the near next. But it is a security risk to rely too much on one partner and it makes sense to have less energy dependence on Russia, or on any one energy source. Less energy interdependence with Russia would probably benefit both sides. For security reasons, it would certainly benefit Europe.

Comments

Related Articles
  • KMG,CNPC agree on expansion of technical cooperation

    2014/12/17 Kazakhstan’s national oil and gas company KazMunaiGas (KMG) and the China National Petroleum Corporation (CNPC) will jointly work on increasing the oil recovery and utilization of the accompanying gas at fields in southern Kazakhstan. The agreement on the expansion of technical cooperation in the oil and gas sector between CNPC and KMG will serve as a basis for this. The agreement was inked in Astana next a conference of the Kazakhstan-China Business Council with the participation of heads of governments of the two nations. The document stipulates that the KMG and CNPC will expand technical cooperation in the oil and gas industry, inclunding in boosting the oil recovery of the oil fields in the ‘South Turgai’ basin in Kazakhstan.
  • South Africa Set On Boosting Investments With China

    2014/12/06 President Jacob Zuma has arrived in China where he is leading a delegation of ministers and businesspeople on a National visit aimed at strengthening bilateral relations, the Presidency said on Tuesday. The two-day visit, scheduled for Thursday and Friday, signals a further consolidation of South African-Sino relations. This is President Zuma's second National visit to China. In 2010, he took 17 Ministers and about 300 businesspeople and signed the Beijing Declaration on a comprehensive strategic partnership with China.
  • Chinese, Cape Verde FMs Hold Talks

    2014/12/05 Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi and his Cape Verde counterpart Tolentino held talks on bilateral ties in Beijing Tuesday. Wang said it was significant to China to cooperate with developing nations, as it believed in the principle that all nations, large or small, were equal. Wang spoke highly of Cape Verde as its outlook on developing bilateral relationships was of a long-term and strategic view. Wang and Tolentino agreed that both sides should deepen political mutual trust, safeguard the common interests of developing nations and strengthen international and regional affairs coordination.
  • South Africa's President Jacob Zuma will be making his second national visit to China

    2014/12/05 South Africa's President Jacob Zuma will be making his second national visit to China between 4 and 5 December 2014. China-South Africa relations have steadily progressed at the bilateral level and beyond, since official relations were established in 1998 - and have been further upgraded to a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership since 2010. Indeed the upcoming national visit highlights the extent relations have evolved since Zuma's 2010 national visit. China has remained South Africa's major trading partner, with trade jumping 32% between 2012 and 2013. Investment is as well slowly diversifying, raising hopes of moving beyond a focus on the resource sector to areas that could generate local employment. However, South Africa, as a diversified economy with relatively strong institutional frameworks and a vocal civil society - and China's increased engagement on the continent - means there are not only areas of convergence but contention as well.
  • President Jacob Zuma arrived in China

    2014/12/05 At the same time as Zuma visited China in 2012, he was awarded an honorary professorship from Beijing's esteemed Peking University. The new Honorary Professor of International Relations used his acceptance speech to promote education initiatives between South Africa and China (the theme of the event), trumpet the government's successes and promote China's role in SA's development. Zuma flew back into China on Wednesday, his initial national visit since re-election, with an entourage in tow. The trip will last until Saturday and separate talks will be held with President Xi Jinping, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang, and top legislator Zhang Dejiang. Zuma is joined by a 100-strong business delegaaation ahead of the South Africa-China Business Forum on Saturday. According to Minister in the Presidency Jeff Radebe, 10 agreements are expected to be signed.