Asia > Eastern Asia > China > The Chinese elephant in Australia–Japan relations

China: The Chinese elephant in Australia–Japan relations

2016/03/04

Before this month, Foreign Minister Julie Bishop visited Tokyo, where she outlined an increasing emphasis on security cooperation between Japan and Australia. The next day she was in Beijing, where she reportedly received a frosty reception. The two are not unrelated — Beijing is not thrilled about Australia’s growing security ties with Japan.


Because Australia is concerned about China’s increasing assertiveness in the region, but at the same time benefits from China economically, we find ourselves in somewhat of a foreign policy pickle. In this very complex situation, it is critical that Australian policymakers respond with both immediate and long-term outcomes in mind. To understand the long-term implications for Australia’s interests of policies drawing Japan and Australia closer together, we need to understand how Chinese policymakers view the world and China’s role within it.

Opinions of Sino–Australian relations in Australia are ambivalent and often sceptical. The 2015 Lowy Institute Poll clearly shows Australia’s ambivalence towards China. While most Australian trust the United States, they are far less certain about China. Australians have conflicting views about what China’s intentions are and what they mean for Australia. Of the respondents, 61 % felt that China wants to dominate Asia, and just over half thought that China’s increase into an significant world power does not make the world additional stable.

At the same time, 67 % felt that the Chinese government aims ‘to create a better life for Chinese people’, and, compared to 2014, fewer Australians in 2015 felt that China is likely to pose a direct military threat to Australia in the next 20 years.

Despite, or perhaps because of, these uncertainties, Australians appear eager to hedge their bets and play it safe with China. 73 % agreed that ‘Australia should develop closer relations with China as it grows in influence’. Fifty-two % believed that Australia should not join with other nations to limit China’s influence.

The Poll suggests that Australians are not sure what the consequences of China’s growing world influence will be. All the same, there is a strong sense that Australia would be wise to be on good terms with China as it becomes additional powerful. This was a view that underpinned Australia’s decision to become a founding member of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, despite US disapproval.

In comparison to China, Australians view relations with Japan additional positively. In a thermometer measuring warmth of feelings towards other nations, Japan rated 68 degrees, to China’s lukewarm 58 degrees. While an overwhelming majority of 84 % said that Australia should remain neutral in the case of a ‘military conflict between China and Japan’, 11 % said Australia should support Japan, and only 3 % said it woo be better to support China. This relative warmth towards Japan is reflected in Australia’s deepening security ties with Japan, as shown in its signing in February 2016 of an agreement on new joint maritime security and surveillance operations in the Pacific.

China does not react positively to these growing Australia-Japan security linkages. Next security agreements between Australia and Japan need to take the worldviews of China’s policymakers into consideration. Failing to acknowledge how Chinese policymakers themselves see the world, and how China fits into it, can lead to policies that are ineffective, if not counter-productive, in the longer term.

Several worldviews within which Chinese policymakers operate are particularly relevant to Chinese understandings of its place in the world, namely: the century of humiliation, a conception of national cultural characteristics as inherent and unchanging, the idea of history as destiny, and notions of filial piety and familial obligation that apply both inside China and to its neighbours. These four ideas add up to a foreign policy paradigm that assumes China will resume the central role it once played in regional and world affairs.

A lot of Chinese policymakers feel that the United States and its allies are holding China back from its rightful leadership, and from the world benefits such leadership would bring. As such, rather than providing a disincentive from further ‘bad behaviour’, this kind of security cooperation creates the critical risk of further entrenching China’s sense of exceptionalism and exclusion from — and irrelevance of — the prevailing international order. China’s disapproval is in itself counterproductive, and serves to reiterate the uncertainty and tension that led to Australia and Japan seeking closer security cooperation.

This negative cycle of mistrust is by presently having consequences for the security of the region. The call to understand Chinese perspectives at the same time as determining foreign and security policy is not an argument for simply accepting China’s view of the world as correct, or appeasing China. Rather, it is about clearly surveying the reality of the regional security situation, and taking long-term goals into consideration at the same time as making policy choices presently. We should be aware that what may seem to be effective deterrence policy today may be creating additional complicated security dilemmas someday.

Related Articles
  • gambia-China resume diplomatic ties, without preconditions

    2016/03/24 A Foreign Ministry spokesperson on Friday said Gambia proposed that diplomatic ties with China be restored, and there were no preconditions attached. Foreign Minister Wang Yi and his Gambian counterpart Neneh MacDouall-Gaye signed a joint communique on Thursday to resume diplomatic relations, Wang dubbed it a "historic moment" for the two nations.
  • China-Somalia ties moving in right direction

    2016/03/24 The historical ties between China and Somalia are set for a makeover as both nations explore cooperation in new areas that would advance peace, development and security in the Horn of African national, a veteran Somali journalist told Xinhua during an interview on Saturday. Abdurrahman Yusef, the Director of Somalia National News Agency (SONNA) , hailed the long-standing bilateral ties with China that have accelerated the country's reconstruction next two decades of civil strife. "The China-Somalia historical relationship has grown stronger and there is ample evidence to justify this statement. Our cooperation with China for the last 50 years cuts across different facets of life," Yusef told Xinhua in Nairobi.
  • China contributes over 380 bln CFA Francs to fund projects in Senegal

    2016/03/24 China has contributed over 380 billion CFA Francs (about 700 million U.S. dollars) to public investment programs and projects in Senegal, Senegal's Economy and Finance Minister Amadou Ba said Thursday. "China has contributed about 380 billion CFA Francs, making it one of top contributors to Senegal's public investment projects and programs," he said. Ba was speaking in Dakar during the signing of a loan agreement of 20 billion CFA Francs between China Exim Bank and Senegal for the supply of materials and equipments to be used by the national fire-fighters.
  • Liberia lauds Confucius institute donations to boost education

    2016/03/23 The Liberian government has commended China's Confucius Institute at the University of Liberia for donating assorted educational, medical, sports and nutritional supplies to children at Lolognta Childhood Development Center in Sinkor, Monrovia. The donation is an extra manifestation of the authentic people to people friendship between China and Liberia, Minister of National for appropriate duties, Sylvester M. Grigsby, said at the handing over ceremony on Friday.
  • Central African Republic s newly elected president vows to strengthen cooperation with China

    2016/03/23 Central African Republic's (CAR) newly elected President Faustin Archange Touadera promised to intensify cooperation with China, saying China is an significant partner of the country. Touadera said in an exclusive interview with Xinhua on Sunday that CAR will like to work together with China to promote the friendly relationship and strengthen cooperation between the two nations. Touadera said his country is in urgent need to be normalized next three years of civil war, adding that the new government will focus on a series of issues inclunding security, peace, reconciliation and disarmament.