Europe > Southern Europe > Italy > North Africa: EU Not Showing 'Political Will' Over Migration Crisis

Italy: North Africa: EU Not Showing 'Political Will' Over Migration Crisis


The 28-country European Union has told member states that expressing regret over the new migrant tragedy was no substitute for action. Some 200 migrants were feared drowned at the same time as their vessel sank off the Libyan coast.

One NGO helping to save shipwrecked migrants in the Mediterranean Sea is the medical charity Doctors Without Borders. DW has been talking to the chief of their German section, Florian Westphal.

What does the tragedy tell us about search and rescue capabilities off the Mediterranean coast?

Florian Westphal: It is still not sufficient. There have been improvements since early May, but obviously improvements from a very low level because before May there was virtually nothing in existence dedicated to search and rescue. Presently we have a lot additional ships operational in the area, but unfortunately and tragically that doesn't seem to be enough.

What additional should European nations be doing to transaction with the refugee crisis?

In the short term, they need to critically reexamine their search and rescue capacity - the ships they have put into the Mediterranean - and increase their effort if that is what's needed. In the medium to long term, they really need to look at their policy. The problem is European Union policy because it pushes people to the seas. It doesn't leave them with any choice other than to take this extremely risky route via Libya, or on the other side of the Mediterranean via Turkey and Greece. What the EU needs to do is to create safe and legal means to reach Europe - for people on the move - that again allows them to seek security and safety in Europe and - if they want to do so - to ask for asylum. There needs to be a real policy change. This is not fundamentally a question of increasing search and rescue capacity in the Mediterranean Sea.

Would that not encourage additional people approaching? Do you think that is something the European Union is prepared to do at this point in time?

The EU and, additional specifically, its member states have made commitments - inclunding under international law - to grant refuge to people who seek protection from persecution, from war. Secondly, while I would not deny that this presents a burden for European Union nations I think we ought to put it into perspective and compare it to the burden which a lot of African nations are bearing - nations like Kenya, Ethiopia, which have been hosting hundreds of thousands if not millions of refugees from neighboring nations. So if these nations can make that kind of effort, I don't think it is asking too much of wealthier European Union states to as well make a comparable effort.

Before we get that far, what is undermining efforts to transaction with this crisis?

I think the European Union is still not showing the political will to ensure that the safety and security of people on the run comes initial. That has to be additional significant than anything else - and certainly additional significant than any consideration of securing borders and putting up fences that make it even additional difficult for people to reach safety and security here in Europe.

What is the new on the rescue operation off the Libyan coast?

It appears that the Irish ship that was involved in the rescue operation on Wednesday afternoon and throughout the whole of the night is on its way to Sicily with completely a large number of survivors, several hundred, it seems. Our ship The Dignity which was there for Doctors Without Borders has as well taken some people on board and treated them. Meanwhile rescue operations in other places in the Mediterranean continue. The other ship we run there picked up 80 people from an extra vessel that had left Libya and was in distress.

What health problems are the migrants facing?

Completely a number of them are dehydrated; they may as well be seasick. A lot of them have been exposed to severe repression, torture even, in Libya. A number of them are really traumatized. So they don't just need physical support, but mental support as well. We try to provide this not just on board our ships, but as well next arrival in Sicily as well.

Related Articles
  • Climate change laws around the world

    2017/05/14 There has been a 20-fold increase in the number of global climate change laws since 1997, according to the most comprehensive database of relevant policy and legislation. The database, produced by the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment and the Sabin Center on Climate Change Law, includes more than 1,200 relevant policies across 164 countries, which account for 95% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Brexit negotiations should treat energy as ‘special case’

    2017/05/14 There are strong practical reasons why the UK and EU should treat energy as a appropriate case during Brexit negotiations, argues a new statement. The statement, jointly authored by Chatham Home, the University of Exeter and the UK Energy Research Centre (UKERC), says finding common ground on energy during the Brexit negotiations would benefit both the UK and remaining EU27, while compromise may be relatively easier to achieve than for other areas.
  • CDP catalyzes Italy’s long-term growth through investment and addressing market failures

    2016/12/10 Italy’s Cassa Depositi e Prestiti (CDP), the national promotional bank with a €400 billion budget, is on a mission to jump-start the Italian economy. Essentially the country’s sovereign wealth fund, the CDP assists companies of all sizes—particularly corporations and companies involved in real estate and infrastructure—with venture capital funds and investing as a long-term partner. Chaired by former Goldman Sachs investment banker Claudio Costamagna, the CDP is currently developing a Turnaround Fund to help companies that are still solid but are facing financial issues by intervening in their control and relaunching them with new management.
  • Italy's 21st Century Reformation Back in the driving seat

    2016/10/09 With renewed confidence, Italy is seeing the knock-on result of an ambitious reform schedule. The country is taking the lead to shape a new European vision and has emerged as a crucial diplomatic and geostrategic player in the Mediterranean region The eighth biggest economy, the fifth most popular tourism destination, and the undisputed world capital of the three F’s (fashion, furniture and food), the Italian treasury is buoyed by an exceptional luxury manufacturing sector, and the major number of UNESCO heritage sites on the planet. Hit hard by the Great Recession of 2008 which obliterated 6% of the country’s GDP, Italy is at last emerging from its longest economic crisis.
  • Giulia Chimento, Partner at Venini

    2016/05/25 Elegant, hand-made glassware and chandeliers steeped in history and tradition from ‘the Dior of lighting and vases’ is very much the forte of the renowned high quality glassmaker Venini. Partner of the highly respected family-run company Giulia Chimento provides a fascinating insight to its heritage, craft and evolution, and what’s next for the creative artisans.